All Weather Painting vs Larson Bros Painting

The experience advantage is real—37 years means they've solved problems most contractors never encounter. But workers comp isn't about quality; it's about financial protection if someone gets hurt on your property. You need to assess whether your homeowner's insurance adequately covers that risk and whether you're comfortable being the primary coverage. The experience matters most if your project has unusual complexity that justifies accepting the liability trade-off.

This could reflect different business models—All Weather may work primarily through referrals or commercial contracts that don't generate online reviews. It doesn't necessarily indicate quality problems, but it does mean you'll need to do more due diligence by requesting direct references. Larson Bros' documented feedback gives you more certainty about what to expect from their current operations.

For straightforward exterior or interior repainting, 16 years is plenty of experience to handle standard situations competently. The gap becomes more meaningful for problem-solving—diagnosing why paint failed prematurely, working with unusual substrates, or restoring historic finishes. If your home has hidden damage, unusual materials, or you've had past coating failures, the additional two decades of troubleshooting experience could matter significantly.

You can certainly ask, but contractors typically can't obtain coverage for a single project—it's an annual policy decision. Some sole proprietors legitimately don't carry it because they work alone, but if All Weather uses employees or subcontractors, the absence is a concern. Ask directly how many people will be on your job site and what their coverage situation is, then make your decision based on that reality.